I Hate the Great Halloween Debate!

Do you get tired of hearing the debate year after year on whether or not Christians should celebrate Halloween??  I know I did!  When my hubby and I started having children we had to make those important decisions for our family.  Will we celebrate Halloween?  Will we do Santa Clause, the Easter Bunny, or the tooth fairy?  I can’t answer those questions for you, but I can tell you about something I started doing and ended up loving it so much I do it every year!

{This post may contain my referral links. You can see my full Disclosure and Cookie Policies or my updated Privacy Policy for more details.}

christmas halloween

It was the last week of October and we were going to a friend’s house to visit.  I was shocked when I walked in her living room and she had it completely decorated for Christmas!  She explained that she loved Christmas so much that she liked decorating early so that she could enjoy it longer.  I LOVED the idea!  I never liked Halloween and this was the perfect way to just skip the whole thing!  Decorating for fall wasn’t something I did either, because you had to take it down for Christmas.  This way, I could decorate for Christmas at Halloween!  It would be a special day for my family and I wouldn’t have to do any extra decorating for Thanksgiving!  I was definitely going to try it.

The next year I put my plan in action.  On the last day of October I took out my Christmas decorations, and my kids helped me put them all up.  My husband thought I was crazy when he walked in the door after work that day!  It only took a couple of days to completely win him over.  He thought it was a great plan!  I was amazed at the positive comments I got throughout November, and EVERYONE loved having it decorated for Christmas at Thanksgiving.  It was a complete WIN!


Now my family looks forward to having Christmas up for 2 months every year. It also works well in Indonesia where we live.  The Indonesians don’t celebrate Halloween, so it makes it easier to skip on to Christmas.  As a matter of fact, the Papuans where we live start putting up “Christmas Huts” around October/November! 

I’m looking forward to pulling Christmas out again this October! 

What do you like to do for the holidays that is a little outside the box?  Is there something you have always wanted to do but never had the guts?  Well, do it!  Just tell people about the crazy lady you read about that puts up Christmas for Halloween!

I would love to hear your living out-of-the-box stories!  Comment below!

Teach Them Diligently Convention 2018


2 thoughts on “Christmas on Halloween?!”

  1. Interesting concept! A definite way to avoid Halloween! Believe me, I dread October. October 1 is when everyone puts up their halloween decorations outside, lights and all in my neighborhood.
    Since you are a homeschooler like me, I want to introduce you to a book, that is part of a curriculum set by My Father’s World. This book completely changed my life forever, in the most beautiful way. And I am so thankful to God! I could speak volumes about this, but I don’t want to overwhelm anyone.
    The book:
    Celebrating Biblical Feast
    In your home or church
    By Martha Zimmerman
    ISBN 9780764228971

    Your concept of Christmas in October is so close to reality in the Bible. Sukkot, the Feast of Tabernacles, in the fall, is when Jesus was born.

    God Bless You and your family!

    1. Jen, Thanks for your comment! I will look up the book you mentioned. It has been a lot easier staying away from the halloween goulishness here in Indonesia, because they don’t do it! I’m always leary of taking my kids into a store in October in the U.S. I appreciate your comment!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *